Is Ottawa using identity politics to hide its vaccination inefficacy?

With regard to the Covid-19 vaccination, Canada is lagging behind MANY countries like Israel, the United Arab Emirates, the UK, the USA, even the heavily bureaucratic European Union, etc.

Our mainstream media (especially the CBC), an extension of our government, tends to ignore (= hide) such information.

Of course, there are supply-chain and other logistical obstacles worldwide (well explained in the Gravitas video below). Bambi still wants to trust that our government officials have been working HARD to secure vaccines since the earliest days of the pandemic.

Yes, Mr. Trudeau may have made the mistake of putting too much faith in China (all his eggs in the same basket), but luckily, he did well by trying to secure vaccines from more than one company since then.

More recently, Mr. Trudeau approached Mr. Modi, the PM of India to ask for help. More vaccines will arrive to us from India within a month. Sadly, Mr. Trudeau’s good move came after having made a diplomatic faux pas with India by interfering in its conflict with its farmers. Mind you, he was on the same page as Mr. Greta Thunberg ? on this one (or at least with those who manipulate her… or her Twitter account).

Anyhow, Mr. Trudeau finally woke up. He came to his diplomatic wisdom. It is nice to see him putting his Canadian fellow citizens’ public safety first (thank you). To appear more genuinely caring to us, it would be perhaps wise to also put aside any arrogance about our country’s performance. We can refrain from giving lessons to the world, especially when Canada seems like the third world of the developed countries.

Related to our domestic affairs, it would be perhaps also helpful if our federal government does not put blame on the provinces and territories… at least in the media. Of course, it is great to see our federal government strategizing the scaling up process with the provinces/territories. Sadly, it is once again a delayed response (but it is never too late). In this crisis and in former ones, Bambi has the impression sometimes that whenever the Feds seem to be stuck or paralyzed by inaction (Trudeau’s typical reaction when overwhelmed), they rely on their best brains, namely Mr. Dominic Leblanc. So, thanks to him for his latest intervention about the vaccines ((https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/feds-meeting-with-provinces-to-strategize-on-scaling-up-domestic-vaccine-capacity-leblanc-1.530731).

Let’s be clear here. Bambi’s issue is not about all the above. Bambi is specifically upset about the use of identity politics to hide the inefficiency thus far. Indeed, instead of using a scientifically-based approach to determine our priority target groups of first vaccination (strictly based on health-related needs), we now seem to be relying on political calculations (ahead of elections? Or out of conviction?). We read about target groups like indigenous people. Why? Is there a logic like remoteness? Age? High comorbidity like obesity or diabetes mellitus, etc.? We also hear about black Canadians. Why? As part of an-at-risk group like healthcare providers or other? For instance, knowing that healthcare providers are the first target group because they are at an increased risk of being exposed to the coronavirus. We need to protect them first as they take care of us. Another target group are perhaps senior citizens. Maybe first those in nursing homes and then those living in their community (some being more remote than others or far from vaccine centres, etc.). Yes, we also think of other vulnerable groups like taxi drivers/bus drivers or the senior inmates or the inmates with underlying health conditions (then the rest of inmates, etc.), etc.

Well, instead of this, we are reading about “black Canadians” or “Indigenous people” or BIPOCS (the silly acronym meaning Black, Indigenous, or People—or deer–of colour ?), etc. If we focus on healthcare providers in a cosmopolitan city like Toronto, chances are they would resemble their city in their diversity. Who cares about their skin colour or where their grand-parents are buried or their religion, etc. We care to protect them ALL. So for sure, the strategy will be naturally equitable then. Same for cab drivers, even those from recent or older immigration in Toronto or Montreal (mind you, in Montreal, chances are they would be of Lebanese or Haitian origins). In contrast, in Sackville, NB, our dear taxi drivers would likely be from the local community (some from other Canadian cities). This means non-immigrants or to use the fancy awful language of our time: non-BIPOC or non-people of colour or non-blacks or… plain boring white in the mind of the woke radicals who are obsessed with race (e.g., Toronto has a task force of black scientists on vaccine equity, imagine: https://www.toronto.ca/news/black-scientists-task-force-on-vaccine-equity/).

https://www.cbc.ca/radio/thehouse/racialized-canadians-vaccine-priority-1.5911952

https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/indigenous-vaccinations-priority-marc-miller-1.5889826

In other terms, why are we playing a “racial” game now? Bambi even read articles that seem to play the “religious” card (making an analogy with the UK). Well, thus far thankfully, even Lebanon did not seem to fall for this silly trap of identity politics, despite the legitimate concerns of citizens about any cheating about the roll out of the vaccination (e.g., corrupt politicians or connected/richer people, etc.).  

To conclude this post, why can’t Canada just focus on target groups truly based on the science and not on identity politics. Eventually, when more vaccine are administered and if depending on new data about the safety of vaccines or the coronavirus mutation, we can perhaps consider adding other target groups vaccine (e.g. pregnant women as their immune system is compromised, etc.).

 

“Academic freedom and freedom of expression”: Luckily, there is a wise, courageous politician in Canada, called Mr. Legault

It is funny because this morning (or was it yesterday night :)?), Bambi shared the following personal thought with her spouse: “I so much wish to see a wise, courageous politician, perhaps Mr. Legault, doing something about this problem… It is about time“. Well, Mr. Legault seems to have listened to Bambi’s wish :).

It is true that education is a provincial responsibility in Canada. However, according to Bambi (not mentioned by Québec PM), there is sadly a negative influence from our federal government (through funding of ideas/programs, perhaps based more on US-imported ideologies, which are becoming like our orthodoxies). Despite the good intentions of course, our federal government (without realizing it) may actually be contributing to the problem described below.

Of course, to this we add the increased intolerance of different opinions. In other places like Lebanon sadly, people/activists can be killed because of their different opinions. In our country, people/activists can be cancelled (or silenced). In both countries, there is fear and this leads to self-censorship.

Well, Québec, the “belle” province (or distinct society) of our beautiful Canada, has a tradition of public debates. It is not afraid of discussions and arguments (it even had two referendums on sovereignty and, more recently, a debate on reasonable accommodations). Perhaps because of that, and to keep preserving its unique culture (being a minority in North America), Québec may be perhaps more talented in pushing back against non-sense when it sees it. Who knows? Ironically, perhaps it would be Québec that could help save the rest of Canada from the potentially toxic influence of this US civilizational malaise (or by extension, the malaise of the Western world in general, which seems to be increasingly losing its points of reference).

This being said, thank you, Mr. Legault for suggesting “a serious chat” (or public debate) on academic freedom and freedom of expression in Québec. Bambi hopes it would be an inspiration to all of us.

Without further due, here is Mr. Legault’s tweet, followed by a quick translation of his beautiful Facebook message (https://www.facebook.com/400223946701308/posts/3855424881181180/?d=n). “Merci bien Monsieur le Premier Ministre du Québec”!

“We hear a lot about academic freedom and free speech these days. I am thinking in particular of the story of the University of Ottawa which shocked a lot of people, myself included.

We see that a handful of radical activists who are trying to censor certain words and works. We see a movement coming here from the United States and frankly, I find that it does not resemble us.

What is really worrying is that more and more people are feeling intimidated. They feel forced to censor themselves for fear of being insulted and reported in the public arena.

Professors are being asked to erase the works of some of our great writers, such as Anne Hébert, Réjean Ducharme, Dany Laferrière or Pierre Vallières. It’s absurd. It goes against the whole idea of ​​the university.

And then it’s not limited to campuses. In the fall, I experienced it myself when activists tried to censor my reading suggestions because I recommended a book by Mathieu Bock-Côté, which dealt precisely with the excesses of political correctness.

Recently, a university lecturer testified in a newspaper that she had been denounced and harassed for using the words “man” and “woman”!

It goes too far. The situation is getting out of hand. I think this is the time to have a serious discussion all together.

The use of certain words can hurt, and the pain of those who feel it should be recognized. On the other hand, their just cause must not be hijacked by radicals who want to censor, muzzle, intimidate and restrict our freedom of speech.

Between injury and censorship, we have to draw a line.

While it may be healthy to question certain conceptions or behaviours and avoid offending or hurting, we should not sacrifice our freedom of expression. We need to stand up so that intimidated people know they have the right to present facts and ideas, and that we will be there to defend them.

The same goes for people who are victims of racism. They need to know that we will not ignore hate speech, racist acts or discrimination.

Freedom of expression is one of the pillars of our democracy. If we start making compromises on this, we risk seeing the same censorship spill over into our media, into our political debates. We will stop wanting to say anything anymore. No one will dare to talk about immigration, for example, if every time you bring it up, you get shouted nonsense. Nobody wants that. Not me anyway.

This problem started with our universities, and I think this is where we are going to have to fix it first. Higher Education Minister Danielle McCann is working on this with academic environments to act quickly.

Our universities should be places of respectful debate, uncensored debate and the search for truth, even when the truth may shock or provoke. We will do what it takes to help our universities protect our freedom of expression.

But we also have a responsibility there. We all have a duty to stand up for our fundamental principles in the face of bullying attempts.

If you start to censor yourself out of fear of being insulted, or if you don’t stand up for someone who is the victim of this, you are playing the radical game. I understand it can be scary, but we have to stand up, stay firm. The more people who refuse to give in to the intimidation of a minority of radicals, the more fear will recede.

Happy Saturday everyone.

Your prime minister”

WHO probe on the coronavirus origins: For the CBC, “WHO team” was “granted full access to sites, personnel”, but Gravitas’ Palki Sharma contradicts this information

First, here is the CBC article:

https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/who-coronavirus-investigation-1.5906617

Second, below you can find the Gravitas‘ short news documentary (out of India).

According to Gravitas, China seems to have obstructed access to raw data of waste water as well as blood samples prior to December, 2019 (citing internal laws or appearing to perhaps having destroying the needed evidence?). One must add that the WHO investigators were provided with “analyzed data” only, instead of “raw data”. Furthermore, China still has the nerve to blame the USA. As Ms. Sharma concluded, “the worst part of all this is that the world is putting up with it.”

Although it is likely not China’s problem that this coronavirus started in this country (it could have happened anywhere else…), the behaviour of the Chinese authorities, at the start of the pandemic and now, is problematic to all of us worldwide.

So, please China, can you learn to be more considerate and genuinely collaborative? It would be a good fresh start on the day following this lunar (New) Year [Happy New Year, by the way!]. After all, it is the year of the Ox, if Bambi understands well. Can you please be like the Ox, that is honest and reliable, whilst being determined“? Thank you.

United Nations’ “Awake at Night”: Ms Sarah Copland, interviewed by Melissa Fleming

What a moving AND inspiring interview with Ms. Sarah Copeland… Ouf. Thank you Ms. Melissa Fleming, the United Nations’ Under-Secretary-General for Global Communications, for your “Awake at Night” interview.

From the UN website, we can read the following:

This week’s guest is Sarah Copland. Sarah first joined the UN as part of the Young Professionals Programme in Political Affairs. In 2015, along with husband Craig, Sarah moved to NYC for her first UN post with the Department of Peacekeeping Operations (DPKO) in the Policy and Best Practices Service. They were in NYC for 4 years, where Isaac was born. The family then moved to Beirut for Sarah’s work on women’s rights and gender equality in the ESCWA Centre for Women.

On August 4th 2020, as Sarah was working and simultaneously preparing for the arrival of her second child, Ethan, she and her family were tragically caught in the vast explosion that caused devastation across Beirut. Isaac, Sarah’s first born son, was killed. Trying to understand her grief, Sarah started writing a blog, and in the process, her words have resonated with others experiencing loss.

Writing helps me organize my thoughts because it’s, it’s a mess up here. There’s just so much going on in my head and it helps others relate to me, I think which in turn helps me because I found in these past few months, I’ve shut down a lot. And it’s through writing that I’m able to connect again. Because once if people can read how I feel, then that sort of opens up a door to be able to connect and talk.”

Here is the interview, both as a podcast (S3-Episode 16: Isaac) and a full transcript:

https://www.un.org/en/awake-at-night/S3-E16-isaac

To Ms. Sarah Copeland, to her spouse Mr. Craig, and their beautiful family (Isaac in heaven and baby Ethan born in October, 2021), Bambi sends her heart… Thank you Ms. Copeland for sharing your story and for all what you did to Beirut and the Arab world (women’s rights/gender equality). Bambi is TERRIBLY sorry for your loss (your adorable Isaac is Beirut’s and our world’s loss too…).

To conclude this post, this Beirut man-made tragedy is still unaccountable, six months after the tragedy. Doesn’t Isaac deserve justice?! As a reminder, a female engineer is still jailed (scapegoat?) whilst all the Lebanese politicians, up to the high levels (President’s office) who knew about the ammonium nitrate for years are enjoying their freedom. The underlying tragedy of Lebanon is that its justice system is both corrupt and politicized. Of course, no other country is immune to this, including us here… and including UN tribunals (i.e., the disappointing verdict about the assassination of former PM Mr. Hariri). Anyhow, Lebanon is sadly a world leader now with regard to systemic corruption. Perhaps related to this, it is also sadly at the end of the bottom list when it comes to quality of life ranking (Bambi thanks Paul for sharing, https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/quality-of-life-rankings). Of note, perhaps Bambi’s eyes missed it, but Venezuela does not appear to be among the list of countries in the link above. Regardless, we know how bad its situation is from its 2020 reported inflation of 3000 percent (https://news.abs-cbn.com/business/02/12/21/venezuela-reports-2020-inflation-of-3000-percent). The question is which country is worse when it comes to hyperinflation, Venezuela or Lebanon? Perhaps it is still Venezuela’s economic model fiasco (yes, extreme socialism can kill entrepreneurship, destroying economies)? However, Venezuelans of Lebanese origins who escaped to Beirut are unsure of the answer, still wondering which is worse than which (https://www.ft.com/content/a7137fa5-0ff4-4248-8814-deb0b5a9e4dd)… One thing is sure: Lebanon seems to be doomed when it comes to intellectual and military sovereignty on its own land (Iran’s hegemony regionally and its related Hezbollah’s influence internally).

Isn’t it disgusting to see the Hezbollah and its (supposedly Christian) ally intimidating clergymen for having participated in the multifaith funeral prayer for Mr. Lokman Slim?

Why are we turning the beautiful, democratic, Lebanon into Syria or Iran?

Indeed, a member of the so-called “Free Patriotic Party” (what is free about it? And what is patriotic?) is calling for the priest who recited a prayer for the dead for Mr. Slim to apologize. Can you imagine?

He is even trying to turn the story into an insult to Christian rituals. How stupid and low can you go in life, Bambi wonders… without having ever heard of the name of this Lebanese politician in her life before?

Another Muslim (Shia) clergyman was paralyzed by fear to the point of apologizing for having participated in the beautiful, multifaith, funeral prayer of Mr. Lokman Slim.

He claimed he did not know to which house he was heading to say a prayer for the dead and whose body he was praying over. He said he was surprised by the cameras (of journalists).

He repeated his loyalty (to Hezbollah), asking people to stop talking about the story. “God forgive those who are talking about me. I made a mistake

Isn’t it sad to see a spiritual man apologizing for praying on the dead body of another human being (who happened to be from his own community on top of that)?

Where is Lebanon heading? Are the masters of these people trustworthy when it comes to nuclear deals, Mr. Biden et al.?

https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20210211-lebanon-multi-faith-service-for-slain-activist-sparks-row

Even wild animals suffer from systemic racism

Mmm, should Bambi be concerned for her fellow wild animals who suffer from systemic racism, it seems?

Well after reading the two articles further below, she is more concerned about humans who suffer from systemic stupidity?

Can we please leave the animals out of our silly ideologies?

Thank you.

https://www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/systemic-racism-affects-wildlife-too-a-q-and-a-with-an-urban-ecologist

https://www.thenewstribune.com/news/local/news-columns-blogs/matt-driscoll/article244966965.html

So, Mr. Trudeau is an expert of American politics now?

A CBC article, by Mr. Alexandra Panetta, entitled “Trudeau’s criticism of Trump cited at U.S. impeachment trial” informs us of the following:

What we witnessed was an assault on democracy by violent rioters, incited by the current president and other politicians,” Trudeau said last month during an address outside of his residence at Rideau Cottage“:

https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/trudeau-trump-impeachment-capitol-1.5910857

Mmm, Mr. Trudeau is an expert of American internal politics now? His criticism is cited at US impeachment trial, which takes place long after/even if Mr. Trump finished his mandate. By the way, why doesn’t this US impeachment trial have a stronger (internal) expert than our own Mr. Justin Trudeau :)?

To conclude this post, it would be nice if Mr. Trudeau re-focuses his attention strictly on being our Prime Minister, especially during this pandemic crisis. Canadians need all his energy to secure more vaccines to protect them… and to deal with all the Covid-19 economic challenges. Thank you!

If money is the sinews of war, why did Mr. Biden quietly withdraw Mr. Trump’s rule on schools’ disclosure of ties to China? Didn’t he just create a Pentagon task force on China to precisely “ensure the American people win”?

Mr. Biden’s heart seems to be torn between two lovers, China and Iran ?.

Seriously, it is often hard to read politicians or to follow them, even when they seem familiar or friendlier.

They can dance in weird ways sometimes, with one step in one direction and the other in another direction.   

They may say all the beautiful sentences in the world, but their actions do not seem to match their words.  

Why is Bambi saying so?

Because Mr. Biden pledged to ‘meet the China challenge and ensure the American people win’. Beautifully articulated goal.

https://www.ft.com/content/dedda549-4279-4931-aec3-03167bb6beae

It would have been even more beautifully meaningful had it not been contradicted by the following news: Mr. Biden withdrew his predecessor’s rule on schools’ disclosure of ties to China (https://www.reginfo.gov/public/do/eoDetails?rrid=131811).

Bambi does not understand the internal politics of our neighbour, but he seems to have proceeded with this decision without consulting Congress. He must have his reasons to be in a rush… Perhaps he does not see the potential danger of ideologies infiltrating his own country, along with true science and artistic exchanges.

How could you be that naive when you are a seasoned politician? Is this possible? Even the province of NB struggled with the similar issue (https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/confucius-institute-programs-china-school-1.5259963).

Another possibility may be that it is a sign that the USA cannot be the winner of the Chinese-American battle (… of ideas, at least). Could it be?

Although Bambi may be wrong, she finds this both odd and worrisome. Indeed, she knows from a second life elsewhere that wars begin with ideas/ideologies… and the rest can become even uglier.

https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/news/biden-trump-rule-schools-disclosing-chinese-state-run-confucius-institutes

Bravo to Saudi Arabia for freeing jailed Ms. Loujain Al-Hathlout. When is Mr. Badawi’s turn? And… by the way, how do Mr. Biden et al. call today’s Huthi attack on Saudi airport?

A picture taken from Naharnet

Ms. Loujain Al-Hathlout, a women’s rights activist has been released from jail after three years (as per France 24, Naharnet, and international media):

https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20210210-prominent-saudi-activist-loujain-al-hathloul-released-from-jail-after-nearly-3-years

Bravo Saudi Arabia for this move!

Bambi hopes Mr. Raif Badawi will be next!

Since this post is about Saudi Arabia, Bambi wonders how Mr. Biden et al. call the latest Huthi attack on Saudi airport? Or the term terrorist does not apply to allies (ie., Iran and their proxy organizations in the Middle East)?

http://www.naharnet.com/stories/en/279307-huthi-attack-on-saudi-airport-leaves-plane-on-fire

For earlier posts on the topic, you may wish to read: